Showing posts with label tips. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tips. Show all posts

Thursday, May 31, 2007

Research Tip: Use an Index

magnifier

Westlaw and LexisNexis are great resources for doing legal research. They have thousands of databases of full-text documents, including statutes, regulations, cases, and articles from law reviews and other legal periodicals.

But searching a full-text database can be time-consuming and frustrating. How many times have you run what seems like a very precise search in a full-text database of journals and law reviews, and ended up having to sort through hundreds of articles in which your search terms appear only in the footnotes.

One way to improve the relevance of your search results is to use a legal periodical index such as LegalTrac or WilsonWeb. Because these indexes typically search just the most important parts of articles, like the title and abstract, they are much more likely to retrieve articles you can use. You can use LegalTrac from any computer on the SIUC campus network, but you must be connected to the law-school network to use WilsonWeb.

Westlaw and LexisNexis also have legal-periodical indexes: both systems have Legal Resource Index, the database that LegalTrac searches, and Westlaw has Index to Legal Periodicals, the WilsonWeb database. The indexes link you to full-text articles available on the system you are using.

Indexes can save you time and improve the relevance of your search results. For more information see:

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

The Importance of Proofreading---and Some Tips

The other night I heard a student telling another how she had avoided a proofreading calamity. During class that night, each student had to get up and argue in support of a motion they had previously turned in. The student realized that she had inadvertently left out the word "not," so she covered her error by arguing the other side of the case. Of course, in the real world, you can't just switch sides.

The student's story reminded me of an unemployment case I attended years ago. The woman seeking unemployment benefits was a law student who had been fired for incompetence by her law-firm employer. Although several errors were given as grounds for her firing, the beginning of the firm's lack of confidence in her abilities stemmed from a near-perfect memo she had prepared. Howevere, she had left out the word "not" in the subject line of the memo. Although the remainder of the memo correctly stated the law, the most prominent sentence was wrong because of one little word.

The difficulty of proofreading is that when you try to proofread something on which you have been working for a long time, you sometimes see what you meant to write, instead of what you did write, so you can miss important errors. I try to avoid this problem by not working on the project for a day or two before my final proofreading. Some people proofread in a different font or font size than they have used while writing. Others find that printing the document forproofreading, instead of reading it on the screen, does the trick.

Eric Waltmire recently posted his tip for How to Proofread Perfectly. Eric recommends having your computer read the document to you while you read along. See Eric Waltmire's Blog for details. (Eric is an SIU Law alum.)

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

ABA Litigation Podcast

headset

The American Bar Association's Section of Litigation has a podcast of "practical tips, tactics, and interviews with today's leading trial attorneys." Each biweekly episode is less than ten minutes long—a very easy way to pick up some practical tips.

Download episodes of the Litigation Podcast: Tips & Tactics for the Practicing Trial Lawyer or subscribe via iTunes or a newsreader or podcatcher. For example:

Monday, March 19, 2007

Appellate Practice Tip of the Week: "Clearly"

The North Dakota Supreme Court posts an "Appellate Practice Tip of the Week" on its website, along with other helpful information for attorneys and members of the public. This week's Appellate Practice Tip is:

The word "clearly" is no substitute for authority or logic.

There are also tips specific to the record, stays, briefs, the appendix, mootness, oral argument, petitions for rehearing, and the Administrative Agencies Practice Act. Some other Appellate Practice Tips to consider as you finalize your brief:

  • Never use many words when a few will do. A longer brief is not necessarily a better brief.
  • Make sure cases and statutes are cited correctly. Make sure cases cited are still good law.
  • At the end of your brief, state clearly and concisely what specific action you are seeking from the appellate court.
  • "Always use your computer's spell check, and never trust it." —Steve Wilbers, Minneapolis Star Tribune
  • Proofread. Then proofread again.

Friday, February 09, 2007

The Meaning of Legal Research Terminology

Please excuse our mess

Legal research terms can sometimes be confusing. If you can't remember the difference between a cited case and a citing reference, between primary authority and mandatory authority, or between session laws and a statutory code, check the law library's Glossary of Legal Research Terms or one of the references listed at the bottom of that page, all of which are available in the law library or on the web.

We recently added Elyse H. Fox, The Legal Research Dictionary: From Advance Sheets to Pocket Parts (2d ed., Leg. Info. Serv. 2006) (KF 240 L43 2006).

Monday, February 05, 2007

Don't Trivialize Your Client's Case

This week's Appellate practice tip from the North Dakota Supreme Court should be applied to trial court briefs as well as to appellate briefs:

"Raise only important issues. Trivial issues detract from important ones."

Friday, December 01, 2006

Research Tip: Read the Stuff You Find

magnifier

We talked about this in class, but it is worth repeating. You are not finished with your research when you find a statute, regulation, or case that seems to match the facts of your research assignment. You have to read each authority that you find to make sure that it really applies to the situation you are researching--and that it says what you think it says.

I was reminded of this tip when I read this entry on The Practice blog, dedicated to "Helping law students and lawyers learn everything they wanted to know about law practice management, but did not learn in law school." The author recounts receiving a motion in which opposing counsel cited to a code section but had not read far enough to realize that the section did not give them grounds to file the motion. He advises: "Just take the extra few minutes to make sure you read the entire section and not just the section that helps you. You may save yourself more work in the end!"

That advice may seem obvious, but apparently it is disregarded far too frequently. I heard a state Supreme Court Justice, speaking to a group of law librarians, express concern about the number of briefs she saw in which it was clear that the attorneys had not read the cases they cited. They quote seemingly perfect language to support their position, but if they had read a few more paragraphs of the quoted case they would have read: "We decline to adopt that approach."

Here is how the Curmudgeon put it: "We must know that the cases that we cite stand for helpful propositions. We must also know, however, that those cases do not hurt our client's position in some way. We do not cite cases that have a sentence or two that supports our client's position, but ultimately hold that our client should lose."

Wednesday, November 29, 2006

Difference Between Official and Unannotated Statutory Codes

magnifier

Some researchers assume that official and unannotated codes are the same thing. They are not the same, and they are used for different purposes. To eliminate any confusion, I will first explain the difference between official and unannotated codes, and then discuss when each should be used.

An official code is one that is published by the government or at its direction. Unofficial codes are sometimes called commercial codes, and they are published by commercial publishers without government direction.

Annotated codes are simply codes that have annotations—references to related judicial decisions, administrative materials, and secondary authorities—in addition to the text of the statutes. Unannotated codes have just the text of the statutes, usually with brief notes indicating when each section was added or amended.

All versions of the same jurisdiction's statutory code, whether official or unofficial, annotated or unannotated, use the same numbering scheme. You can use the same citation to look up a statute in any current code, even though the code abbreviation and date parenthetical are different. That is why you don't need parallel citations for statutes.

Although most official codes are unannotated and most unofficial codes are annotated, that is not always the case. Some of you have already used an unofficial unannotated code on Westlaw. For Illinois, the database IL-ST-ANN is the annotated code and IL-ST is the unannotated code. They are both unofficial.

The advantage of using an unannotated code is that it is much smaller. When you search an unannotated code online, you are only searching the statute, so you don't get false search results where your terms appear only in the annotations and not in the text of the statute.

The importance of official codes is that many publishers, including most law school journals and law reviews, require you to cite to the official code if the statute has been around long enough to have been incorporated into the official code. Since all the codes for a jurisdiction are numbered the same, you can do all your research in an unofficial code and use the official code for your final citation check—to be sure that your cited statutes are included in the unannotated code and to get the date for the parenthetical.

See also Printing Just the Statute and Searching Just the Text of Statutes.

Wednesday, November 08, 2006

Research Tip: Printing Just the Statute

magnifier

When you retrieve a statute on Westlaw or LexisNexis, you get not only the statute, but also all the annotations added by the company. The annotations are helpful for expanding your research, but they can add many pages to your print job. Follow the instructions below to print a statute without the annotations.

On Westlaw, to print just the statute itself you must limit the display before you go to the print options. In the lower right corner, click on Tools and select Limit Display by Fields. To print a statute without annotations, click in the box to the left of Substantive-Doc and then click on the OK button at the bottom of the screen.

On LexisNexis, you can either customize the document view and then print, or go into print and then customize the view. To customize the document view before printing, click on Custom in the upper left corner. To print a statute without annotations, clear all the checkboxes except the box for the Unanno segment and click on the OK button. If you go into the LexisNexis print options first, choose Custom from the Document View drop-down menu and select the segments to be printed.

See also Searching Just the Text of Statutes.

Tuesday, October 31, 2006

Research Tip: How Current Is Your Source?

magnifier

Most of us instinctively assume that online sources will be more current than print sources. That is not always the case, even with premium services like LexisNexis or Westlaw.

This semester, I had my Lawyering Skills students use the Missouri statutory code for one of their legal research exercises. While preparing the answer sheet, I was surprised to see that the MO statutory code section on LexisNexis had this statement about currentness: "Current through all 2005 legislation." I was sure that this had to be a mistake, so I investigated.

I started with the books. The pocket-parts for Vernon's Annotated Missouri Statutes in print, which we received in February, are current through the end of 2005!

The MO statutory code section on Westlaw had this statement about currentness: "current through the end of the Second Regular Session of the 93rd General Assembly (2006)." Westlaw's Scope information for the database states that "State Revisor's corrections are not incorporated until they are received from the state."

The Source Description for the LexisNexis Missouri Annotated Statutes says that the statutes are updated annually. I confirmed this information with a LN reference attorney, who told me that the database is scheduled to be updated after Thanksgiving, when LN receives the new code from the state and after the editorial enhancements are added.

Missouri only updates its official code annually, and the Missouri Revised Statutes on the General Assembly website has this warning, entitled Frequency of Statute Updates: "As provided in section 3.125 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri 2000, the statutes of Missouri are permitted to be published once a year or every two years. In compliance with this section, the statutes on this web site are updated only once a year."

Of course, you can always use a legislative service to update a statutory code, whether you are doing research using books, LexisNexis, or Westlaw. You just don't expect to have to do so much updating when you are using an online annotated code.

Related research tip: Is It Still Good Law?

Sunday, October 22, 2006

Research Tip: FirstGov Search Upgrade

FirstGov Search screenshot

The government web portal, FirstGov.gov, has upgraded its Search to give users the choice of searching federal and state government websites, just news, or just images. The Web search option includes news and images in its search results. FirstGov Search just received a major overhaul in January, finally becoming a useful research tool, and it is now even better.

Once you have chosen a Web, Images, or News search, click on Advanced Search to make your search even more specific. For example, with a Web search, you can limit your search to federal sites or to a specific state. With a News search, you can limit your search to news from a specific source. See Search Tips for other options.

Search results are categorized using Vivísimo's clustering technology, and they can be sorted by topic, agency, or source. On some search-results screens there is a tabbed box at the top with selected links to FAQs, forms, jobs, and podcasts. Other search results may be topped by blocks of categorized news links. Featured images may be displayed in a box below the list of clusters.

For an excellent review of FirstGov Search as both a search tool and an information discovery tool, see FirstGovSearch Adds Image and News Search and Continues to Provide Dynamic Clustering on ResourceShelf.

See also Peggy Garvin, The Government Domain: FirstGov becomes First in Government Search on LLRX.com.

Friday, August 25, 2006

Research Tip: Is It Still Good Law?

magnifier

One of the most important steps in any legal research project is determining whether the statutes, regulations, and cases that you want to cite are still "good law." This process goes by a number of terms: updating, cite checking, verifying, or validating. You may also hear it called Shepardizing or KeyCiting, after the two big citators. These terms always include, at a minimum, determining whether the authorities you cite are still applicable and current.

Whether something is good law, and how you make that determination, depends on the type of authority that you want to cite. We will cover how to determine if an authority is still good law when we cover each different type of authority, but here is an overview.

A statute cannot be good law if it has been repealed or declared unconstitutional. A regulation cannot be good law if it exceeds the statutory delegation of authority or is inconsistent with the authorizing statute. A case cannot be good law if it has been reversed or overruled, or if the statute on which it was based has been changed.

To determine whether a statute is still good law, you need to check when the statutory code you are using was last updated, and then check the session laws for statutes enacted since that update. For statutory codes in print, check the pocket part or supplemental pamphlets shelved with the code. You must also check to see if any cases have held the statute to be unconstitutional.

The process for determining whether a regulation is still good law is similar to the process for statutes. Although publishing schedules and arrangements vary from state to state, generally you must check when the regulatory code was last updated, and then check the register for regulations adopted since that update. You must also check the authorizing statute, as described in the previous paragraph.

To make sure that a case is still good law, you must check to see if any subsequent cases have reversed or overruled it. See our research guides on citators. You must also check the statutory code to see if any statutes enacted since the case was decided have changed the common law or statute on which your case was based.

Legal resources on the web can be at least as out-of-date as print resources, and it can be difficult to tell when they were last updated. Check carefully to be sure you know when the law on a website was last updated, not just when some feature of the site was updated. See Evaluating Websites and Other Information Resources.

Making sure that the statutes, regulations, and cases are good law is a lot of work, but it is much better than relying on research that may no longer be current or applicable.

Wednesday, August 02, 2006

Research Tip: Researching Old Statutes

magnifier

In research classes, we emphasize updating your legal research because it is always important to have the most current information possible.

But sometimes you need to know what the law was on a specific date in the past. Maybe you want to rely on a court decision that was based on a statute that has since been amended or repealed. Maybe you represent a client who was injured when a different version of the relevant statute was in effect.

Unfortunately, there are probably no free web resources that will have what you need. Depending on what resources you have available to you, choose one of the following approaches.

If you are near a large law library, such as a state, court, or university law library, they may have the statutory code for the year you need, either in paper or micro format.

If you have access to Westlaw or LexisNexis, they have historical or archived statutes back to the late 1980's or early 1990's. On LexisNexis, go to States Legal - U.S. > [your state] > Statutes & Regulations > Legislative Archive. On Westlaw, go to U.S. State Materials > Other U.S. States > [your state]> Statutes & Legislative Materials > Historical Statutes Annotated.

If you have a citation to a statute that has been renumbered and you have the current statutory code, go to the tables in the Index volume(s). There should be a table that will give you the current citation for the old statute. Then go to the current version of the statute and check the credit and history at the end of the statute to see when the statute was changed.

If you cannot find a copy of the statutory code for the year you need, you will have to use the credit and history at the end of the current statute to reconstruct the previous versions from session laws.

Don't worry if this sounds complex. It will make more sense after you have taken Lawyering Skills. And if you need help, just ask a law librarian. We're here to help.